COMPARISON OF SURGICAL SITE INFECTION IN PATIENTS UNDERGOING SKIN CLOSURE WITH STAPLES VS. SUTURES IN CLEAN ELECTIVE SURGERIES

B AFSAR; I ANWER; AJ TARAR; S SIKANDAR; H GHAFFAR; MU KHAN

doi:10.54112/bcsrj.v2024i1.1221

Authors

B AFSAR Department of General Surgery, Shaikh Zayed Hospital, Lahore, Pakistan
I ANWER Department of General Surgery, Shaikh Zayed Hospital, Lahore, Pakistan
AJ TARAR Department of General Surgery, Lahore General Hospital, Lahore, Pakistan
S SIKANDAR Department of General Surgery, Shaikh Zayed Hospital, Lahore, Pakistan
H GHAFFAR Department of General Surgery, Shaikh Zayed Hospital, Lahore, Pakistan
MU KHAN Department of General Surgery, Shaikh Zayed Hospital, Lahore, Pakistan

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.54112/bcsrj.v2024i1.1221

Keywords:

Pain, Sutures, Staples, Thyroidectomy, Cosmetic Outcomes, Wound Complications

Abstract

Thyroidectomy is a common surgical procedure with various techniques for wound closure, including dermal staples and intradermal suturing. Each method has potential advantages and disadvantages, particularly in terms of wound complications, cosmetic outcomes, and postoperative pain. Understanding which technique offers better outcomes in these areas can guide surgeons in selecting the most appropriate method for skin closure after thyroidectomy. Objective: To compare wound complications, cosmetic outcomes, and pain scores between skin closure with dermal staples and intradermal sutures in patients undergoing thyroidectomy. Methods: A prospective study was conducted in the Surgical Department of Sheikh Zayed Hospital, Lahore, from August 2023 to August 2024. The study included 100 adult patients undergoing thyroidectomy for thyroid disease. The patients were randomly divided into two groups: Group A (n=50) received wound closure with dermal staples, and Group B (n=50) received intradermal suturing. Postoperative assessments were conducted at 1, 4, 12, and 24 weeks to evaluate wound complications, cosmetic outcomes, and pain scores. Cosmetic outcomes were measured using the Stony Brook Scar Evaluation Scale and Manchester Scar Scale. Pain was assessed using the Visual Analog Scale (VAS). Results: No surgical site infections were reported in either group. At the 24-week follow-up, cosmetic outcomes measured by the Stony Brook Scar Evaluation Scale were significantly better in Group A (4.12 ± 1.0) compared to Group B (3.32 ± 1.17) (p=0.027). Similarly, the Manchester Scar Scale score was higher in Group A (7.83 ± 1.34) than in Group B (9.20 ± 2.26) (p=0.033), indicating better cosmesis with staples. However, pain scores were significantly higher in Group A than in Group B both immediately after surgery and at the 4- and 12-week follow-ups. Conclusion: The use of dermal staples in thyroidectomy demonstrated better cosmetic outcomes and wound healing compared to intradermal suturing. However, patients who received staples experienced significantly more postoperative pain. While dermal stapling is a safe and effective alternative for skin closure, further studies with larger populations are necessary to corroborate these findings and guide clinical practice.

Downloads

Download data is not yet available.

References

Teoh L-Y, Chong S-S, Hoh S-Y, Teoh M-S, Ng K-L. A comparison of aesthetic outcome between tissue adhesive and subcuticular suture in thyroidectomy wound closure in a multiracial country: a randomized controlled trial. Asian journal of surgery. 2019;42(5):634-40.

Lee K, Ward N, Oremule B, Mani N. Optimal wound closure techniques for thyroid and parathyroid surgery: a systematic review of cosmetic outcomes. Clinical Otolaryngology. 2019;44(6):905-13.

Huang Y-H, Chen C, Lee C-H, Loh E-W, Tam K-W. Wound closure after thyroid and parathyroid surgery: a meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials. Scandinavian Journal of Surgery. 2019;108(2):101-8.

Bhettani MK, Rehman M, Khan MS, Altaf HN, Khan KH, Farooqui F, et al. Safety and cost-effectiveness of LigaSure® in total thyroidectomy in comparison with conventional suture tie technique. Cureus. 2019;11(12).

Yaqoob M, Irfan S, Randhawa SR, Mujahid MD, Zafar S, Sajid M. Intraoperative and postoperative blood loss in subtotal thyroidectomy using ligasure versus conventional thread knot and cautery. Annals of Punjab Medical College. 2022;16(1):65-8.

Cochetti G, Abraha I, Randolph J, Montedori A, Boni A, Arezzo A, et al. Surgical wound closure by staples or sutures?: Systematic review. Medicine. 2020;99(25):e20573.

Correnti C, Blankenship K, Ufkes N, Strasswimmer J. Sutures, Adhesives, Staples, and Other Closure Technologies. Evidence-Based Procedural Dermatology. 2019:175-212.

Mackeen AD, Sullivan MV, Schuster M, Berghella V. Suture compared with staples for skin closure after cesarean delivery: a systematic review and meta-analysis. Obstetrics & Gynecology. 2022;140(2):293-303.

Zardari IA, Khowaja MA, Jamali AH, Ghumro AH, Dahri FJ, editors. Postoperative wound closure and cosmetic outcomes of sutures and staplers in thyroid surgery at tertiary care hospital. Medical Forum Monthly; 2019.

Naseer S, Khan TH, Gul A, Mumtaz N, editors. Comparison of the Skin Closures Using Staples Versus Prolene Sutures in Patients Undergoing Clean Elective Abdominal Surgeries. Medical Forum Monthly; 2024.

Shobab L, Burman KD, Wartofsky L. Sex differences in differentiated thyroid cancer. Thyroid. 2022;32(3):224-35.

Huang J, Ngai CH, Deng Y, Pun CN, Lok V, Zhang L, et al. Incidence and mortality of thyroid cancer in 50 countries: a joinpoint regression analysis of global trends. Endocrine. 2023;80(2):355-65.

Kiran N, Adeel B, Abbasi MK, Malik AI, Aslam N, Sharif S. Histopathological Characteristics and Incidence of Thyroid Carcinoma in a Tertiary Care Hospital of Pakistan-A retrospective study. Pakistan Journal of Medical & Health Sciences. 2022;16(12):230-.

Agilinko J, Tan P. A double-blinded randomised controlled trial–do subcuticular non-absorbable skin sutures have a better aesthetic outcome than skin staples in large wound closures? GMS Interdisciplinary plastic and reconstructive surgery DGPW. 2019;8.

Akram K, Akhtar UB, Janjua OS, Zahra R, Ahmed T, Jabbar M. Comparison of Skin Staples Versus Prolene Sutures for Closure of Neck Dissection Incisions in Terms of Aesthetics and Wound Healing. Pakistan Journal of Medical & Health Sciences. 2022;16(10):921-.

Qin C, Li T, Zhao B, Wang Y, Li Z, Cao H, et al. Subcuticular Sutures versus Staples in Reducing Surgical Site Infections after Open Abdominal Digestive Surgery: A System Review and Meta-Analysis of Randomized Controlled Trials. Surgical Infections. 2021;22(9):877-83.

Chandrasekaran N, Manokaran SV, Harish Babu Jayakaran DGSG, Subash Y. Comparison of surgical site infection in post-op patients for whom wound closure is done using staplers and sutures. International Journal of Orthopaedics. 2023;9(1):33-6.

Min JC, Jeon D, Kim HB, Kim EK, Eom JS, Han HH. Comparison of long-term abdominal scarring after DIEP flap reconstruction: conventional dermal sutures versus INSORB dermal staples. Archives of Aesthetic Plastic Surgery. 2024;30(3):90-3.

Malik J, Javed N, Rana G, Shoaib M, Ishaq U, Chauhan H. Outcomes of intracutaneous sutures in comparison with intracutaneous staples in cardiac implantable-electronic device pocket closure. Anatolian Journal of Cardiology. 2021;25(10):716.

Redha AGM, Jaber AA, Nassir AM. Staples Vs Subcuticular Sutures For Skin Closure In Inguinal Hernia Repair: A Comparative Study. Group. 2021;2(2.35):0.36.

Feng J, Jiang X, Zhi Z. Subcuticular sutures versus staples for skin closure in patients undergoing abdominal surgery: A meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials. Plos one. 2021;16(5):e0251022.